T1strongest T2lean T3weak reject / n/a
Candidate HermesChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity Board
LeBron James
Under 35.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists
T2T2T3 Win
Vidal Bruján
Under 1.5 Total Bases
T3T2 Win
Matthew Liberatore
Over 1.5 Pitcher Walks Allowed
T3T2T2T1 Win
PASS

All 4 harnesses independently recommended SKIP. No candidate cleared the survival-first threshold: LeBron had superstar usage risk and a 3/10 recent rate, Bruján was a Coors total-bases under with thin edge, and Liberatore had role/innings dependency that couldn't be confirmed pre-game.

✓ Correct

No official bet placed; Martingale ladder unchanged. Board went 3-0: LeBron 31 PRA (win), Bruján 0 TB (win), Liberatore 3 BB over 6.0 IP (win). Opportunity-cost PASS, but correct discipline under survival-first rules.

LeBron James
Lakers @ Thunder · 8:30 PM
Win
Under 35.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists -118
Rithmm
62.1%
BE
54.1%
DTM
17.6%
Recent
L10 3/10
30.0 PRA
Vidal Bruján
Mets @ Rockies · 2:10 PM
Win
Under 1.5 Total Bases -142
Rithmm
60.5%
BE
58.7%
DTM
4.5%
Recent
1.1 total bases
Matthew Liberatore
Cardinals @ Padres · 9:10 PM
Win
Over 1.5 Pitcher Walks Allowed -138
Rithmm
60.9%
BE
58%
DTM
6.9%
Recent
L7 5/7
2.0 walks allowed
Hermes
PASS
✓ Correct

Official PASS preserved the Martingale sequence. Board went 3-0 — all candidates won — but no official bet was placed. PASS remains correct discipline under survival-first rules.

ChatGPT
SKIP
✓ Correct

SKIP correct officially. Paper lean was LeBron U35.5 PRA, which won with 31 PRA. Bruján was rejected (Coors/one-swing) and Liberatore downgraded to T3 due to walk-prop volatility.

Claude
SKIP
✓ Correct

SKIP correct officially. Conditional paper lean was Liberatore O1.5 BB pending start confirmation; he pitched 6.0 IP with 3 BB, so the paper lean won. LeBron was hard-rejected due to 3/10 recent form.

Gemini
SKIP
✓ Correct

SKIP correct officially. Paper lean was LeBron U35.5 PRA, which won with 31 PRA. Gemini's Coors one-swing rejection of Bruján was also directionally correct (0 TB, but the risk profile was real).

Perplexity
SKIP
✓ Correct

SKIP correct officially. Paper lean was Liberatore O1.5 BB (T1 rating), which won with 3 walks over 6.0 IP. Perplexity was the only harness to rate Liberatore Tier 1 and Bruján Tier 2 (inverse of most).