T1strongest T2lean T3weak reject / n/a
Candidate HermesChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity Board
Brandon Marsh
Under 1.5 Total Bases
T3T3T3T3 Loss
LeBron James
Under 35.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists
T2T1T2T1 Loss
Nico Hoerner
Under 1.5 Total Bases
T3T2T3T3 Win
Kyle Tucker
Under 1.5 Total Bases
T3T2T3T3 Win
PASS

Only one plausible candidate (LeBron Under 35.5 PRA) had conditional harness support, but a risk-adjusted confidence of ~57–63% with Luka-out usage risk was insufficient for a Level 1 Martingale recovery spot.

✓ Correct

LeBron landed at 37 PRA, losing by 1.5. PASS preserved the Martingale sequence. Board went 2-2: Marsh lost with 3 TB, LeBron lost at 37 PRA, while Hoerner and Tucker each finished with 1 TB.

Brandon Marsh
vs Athletics · 5:40 PM
Loss
Under 1.5 Total Bases -148
Rithmm
61.6%
BE
59.7%
DTM
4.7%
Recent
L10 5/10
1.6 TB
LeBron James
@ Thunder · 7:30 PM
Loss
Under 35.5 Points + Rebounds + Assists -114
Rithmm
61.5%
BE
53.3%
DTM
17.7%
Recent
L10 3/10
30.2 PRA
Nico Hoerner
vs Reds · 6:40 PM
Win
Under 1.5 Total Bases -144
Rithmm
60.7%
BE
59%
DTM
4.1%
Recent
L10 6/10
1.7 TB
Kyle Tucker
@ Astros · 7:10 PM
Win
Under 1.5 Total Bases -151
Rithmm
61.9%
BE
60.2%
DTM
4.5%
Recent
L10 5/10
1.5 TB
Hermes
PASS
✓ Correct

Official PASS recommendation was correct. The forced-action fallback LeBron U35.5 PRA lost by 1.5 PRA (37 actual). Martingale sequence preserved.

ChatGPT
SKIP
72% skip confidence
✓ Correct

Correctly identified Luka-out usage burden and LeBron's poor L10 as disqualifiers. Forced pick LeBron would have lost by 1.5 PRA.

Claude
LeBron U35.5 PRA (-114)
62% true win probability
✗ Loss

Picked the best non-fragile structure but underweighted the usage/tail risk. LeBron landed at 37 PRA, losing by 1.5.

Gemini
SKIP
100% skip confidence
✓ Correct

Best discipline read. Correctly rejected both the fragile MLB cluster and LeBron's 3/10 recent form. No action taken.

Perplexity
LeBron U35.5 PRA (-114)
58% practical win probability
✗ Loss

Correctly identified the only non-fragile candidate, but the 57–60% practical confidence was not enough for a survival-first Martingale leg. LeBron lost by 1.5 PRA.