T1strongest T2lean T3weak reject / n/a
Candidate HermesChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity Board
Jarrett Allen
Under 1.5 Blocks
T3T2T3T3 Win
Detroit Tigers
Over 1.5 Run Line
T2T1T2T2 Win
Atlanta Braves
Over 0 Moneyline
T2T2T3T3 Win
Jack Leiter
Over 1.5 Walks Allowed
T3T3T3T3 Win
PASS (paper lean: Tigers +1.5 -161)

Max-two-elimination review eliminated C1 (blocks under fragility) and C3 (thin moneyline, ~0.6pp cushion). Remaining board: C2 Tigers +1.5 and C4 Leiter walks. C2 is the paper lean but not an official Experiment Bet — Martingale level was unknown and no candidate cleared recovery-grade.

✓ Correct

PASS protected the official track. Full board swept 4-0: Allen 1 block (WIN), Tigers 3-2 over Blue Jays (WIN), Braves 3-2 over Red Sox (WIN), Leiter 3 walks in 7.0 IP (WIN). High-confidence opportunity-cost PASS.

Jarrett Allen
vs Pistons · 6:00 PM
Win
Under 1.5 Blocks -114
Rithmm
64.2%
BE
53.3%
DTM
23.6%
Recent
L10 2/10
0.86 blocks
Detroit Tigers
vs Blue Jays · 5:45 PM
Win
Over 1.5 Run Line -161
Rithmm
67.2%
BE
61.7%
DTM
14.4%
Recent
L10 4/10
Tigers -0.7
Atlanta Braves
vs Red Sox · 6:15 PM
Win
Over 0 Moneyline -153
Rithmm
61.1%
BE
60.5%
DTM
1.5%
Recent
L10 6/10
Braves 4.5 - Red Sox 3.1
Jack Leiter
@ Astros · 7:10 PM
Win
Over 1.5 Walks Allowed -153
Rithmm
62.3%
BE
60.5%
DTM
4.5%
Recent
L8 4/8
1.9 walks allowed
Hermes
PASS (paper lean: Tigers +1.5)
✓ Correct

Max-two-elimination review eliminated C1 (Allen blocks) and C3 (Braves ML). Paper lean C2 Tigers +1.5 won. Full board swept 4-0; official track took no Martingale risk.

ChatGPT
SKIP (paper: Tigers +1.5)
65% practical confidence for paper lean
✓ Correct

Official SKIP avoided Martingale risk; paper lean C2 Tigers +1.5 won 3-2. Conservative stance was process-correct on an unknown-level series.

Claude
C2 Tigers +1.5 (conditional)
63% win probability discounted from Rithmm
✓ Correct

Tigers beat Blue Jays 3-2; +1.5 covered easily. Conditional T1 read was the most accurate harness call on the board.

Gemini
SKIP (paper: Tigers +1.5)
6% confidence /10 for paper lean C2
✓ Correct

Official SKIP stayed disciplined; paper lean C2 won. Full visible board swept 4-0 — highest-confidence board in recent sample.

Perplexity
SKIP (paper: Tigers +1.5 if forced)
55% subjective confidence for paper lean
✓ Correct

Strict PASS was process-correct. Paper lean C2 won despite confidence being downgraded to ~55% from Rithmm's 67.2% due to L10 and juice concerns.