T1strongest T2lean T3weak reject / n/a
Candidate HermesChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity Board
Cincinnati Reds
Over 1.5 Run Line
T2T1T1T1 Win
Minnesota Twins
Over 0 Moneyline
T2T2T2T2 Loss
Will Warren
Under 5.5 Pitcher Strikeouts
T3T3T3T3 Win
Braxton Garrett
Under 4.5 Pitcher Strikeouts
T3T3T3T3 Win
CONDITIONAL EXPERIMENT BET at Level 0: Reds +1.5 -167

Reds +1.5 had unanimous harness support as the best survival-first candidate: highest Rithmm win chance, strongest DTM, broad T1/T2 tiering, and the only meaningful structural cushion on the board. Twins ML was a reasonable cheaper backup but lacked run-line protection, while both pitcher-K unders were consensus recovery avoids because of thin edges and single-player fragility.

✓ Correct

Reds beat the Phillies 4-1, so the conditional pick won outright and the board finished 3-1. Twins ML was the lone loser; both rejected K unders won but remain process-correct recovery avoids. No placed ticket was logged, so this is a winning official recommendation / paper-tracked conditional pick rather than confirmed bankroll impact.

Cincinnati Reds
@ Phillies · 5:40 PM
Win
Over 1.5 Run Line -167
Rithmm
67.1%
BE
62.5%
DTM
12%
Recent
L10 5/10
Reds -0.6
Minnesota Twins
vs Astros · 6:40 PM
Loss
Over 0 Moneyline -136
Rithmm
62.3%
BE
57.6%
DTM
11.1%
Recent
L10 6/10
Astros 4.2 - 5.8 Twins
Will Warren
vs Blue Jays · 6:05 PM
Win
Under 5.5 Pitcher Strikeouts -162
Rithmm
62.9%
BE
61.8%
DTM
2.7%
Recent
L9 2/9
4.5 Pitcher Strikeouts
Braxton Garrett
vs Braves · 3:10 PM
Win
Under 4.5 Pitcher Strikeouts -148
Rithmm
60.9%
BE
59.7%
DTM
3.1%
Recent
L1 1/1
3.8 Pitcher Strikeouts
Hermes
Reds +1.5
✓ Correct

Hermes made Reds +1.5 the conditional Experiment Bet / Level 0 starter candidate and it won outright, 4-1. No actual ticket, stake, book, or user override was logged, so bankroll impact remains unconfirmed.

ChatGPT
Reds +1.5
✓ Correct

Correct top candidate. ChatGPT picked Reds +1.5 as the least fragile structure and correctly kept recovery eligibility conservative because of the -167 price.

Claude
Reds +1.5
65% ~65%; B+ grade
✓ Correct

Correct top candidate. Claude gave Reds the only Tier 1 grade, with Level 1 recovery possible only after checking the -167 stake math.

Gemini
Reds +1.5
✓ Correct

Correct top candidate. Gemini emphasized the one-run cushion and highest Rithmm win chance, while warning that the road-team no-bottom-9 setup and heavy price were the main failure modes.

Perplexity
Reds +1.5
✓ Correct

Correct top candidate. Perplexity treated Reds +1.5 as the safest structural leg, with Twins ML only a bankroll-relief backup if the -167 sequence exposure broke the cap.